Everyone takes reviews into consideration, especially when these reviews are well-researched. The time for Sheiner Construction has come. We made a Trustworthiness Review, deep researched copy. This is what we have found:
Customer Reviews of Sheiner Construction Across Multiple Platforms
Sheiner Construction has earned overwhelmingly positive customer feedback on multiple review sites. Across Yelp, Google, and Houzz, the company maintains an “Excellent” 5.0-star average based on 90+ reviews (Sheiner Construction San Diego | Kitchen and Bathroom Remodeling, Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io). Many clients praise the team’s communication, honesty, and attention to detail. For example, one homeowner on Angi (Angie’s List) said “I could not be happier…constant communication…[and] attention to detail was great” (Sheiner Construction Reviews – San Diego, CA | Angi). Another described the finished work as “like the kitchen came out of a designer magazine…Every detail was taken care of and we couldn’t be happier” (Sheiner Construction San Diego | Kitchen and Bathroom Remodeling, Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io). Numerous reviews commend project manager “Didi” (Yedidyah Sheiner) for being responsive and “honest…not to push prices up” – even guiding some customers to other specialists for very small jobs rather than upselling (Sheiner Construction San Diego | Kitchen and Bathroom Remodeling, Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io) (Sheiner Construction San Diego | Kitchen and Bathroom Remodeling, Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io).
Negative feedback is exceedingly rare. Out of over 100 total online reviews, only a handful (roughly 3) are rated 1-star, but were deleted after TrustIndex found them as SPAM (Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io).
As per Joseph Sheiner, co-founder at Sheiner Construction, “most probably those 3 reviews were from bad-intentioned competitors.”
These isolated low ratings are not prominently featured on major platforms, and no common complaint theme emerges from available information. The Better Business Bureau (BBB) reports zero customer complaints filed against Sheiner Construction in the past three years (Sheiner Construction | BBB Complaints | Better Business Bureau). Overall, the near-unanimous positivity of reviews – spanning Yelp, Google, Angi, and Houzz – indicates a high level of customer satisfaction.
Project Quality and Workmanship
Client reviews suggest Sheiner Construction delivers high-quality workmanship and solid project outcomes. Homeowners frequently highlight the craftsmanship and finish of remodels. One detailed reviewer noted the crew “demonstrated exceptional craftsmanship and used high-quality materials, ensuring durability and longevity” in both an accessory dwelling unit and a kitchen remodel (Sheiner Construction San Diego – Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io). Even when unexpected issues arose (such as a bathtub that cracked during installation), the company addressed them promptly and at no extra cost to the client, honoring their quality guarantees (Trustindex.io). Multiple clients mention that projects were completed on schedule or even “ahead of schedule”, without compromising quality (Trustindex.io).
Sheiner’s attention to detail is a recurring theme. In reviews, customers describe “fine details like tile placement” being “closely followed” to specifications (Trustindex.io). Team members (such as foreman Eddy) are described as “total rock-stars” with “great attention to detail” (THE BEST 10 GENERAL CONTRACTORS in IMPERIAL BEACH, CA). This focus on workmanship extends to small projects as well: even when a job was too minor for the company to take on, the owner personally provided advice to ensure the homeowner got a proper fix (Trustindex.io). Overall, the consensus is that Sheiner Construction’s project quality meets or exceeds expectations, with finished renovations that “look amazing” and hold up well.
Licensing and Accreditation Status
Sheiner Construction is fully licensed in California. It holds an active California “B” General Building Contractor license (License #1083621) (Sheiner Construction on BuildZoom), which was verified as current through at least January 2025. The license ensures the company met state requirements for experience, passed exams, and maintains bonding & insurance. BuildZoom – a contractor tracking service – confirms the license status and gives Sheiner a high-performance score of 98, ranking it in the top 16% of over 336,000 licensed CA contractors (BuildZoom) (BuildZoom). This suggests compliance with regulations and a strong track record of permit history and client satisfaction.
In terms of accreditation, Better Business Bureau records show Sheiner Construction is not BBB-accredited (many firms choose not to pay for BBB membership). However, BBB currently assigns the company an “A+” rating (Sheiner Construction on Better Business Bureau). An A+ is the highest possible rating, reflecting that BBB has no known issues with the business’s complaint history or operations. On HomeAdvisor/Angi, Sheiner has earned multiple quality badges: the company is marked as a “Top Rated” and “Elite Service Professional,” and notably received the Angi Super Service Award (a recognition for exceptional service and customer reviews) (Sheiner Construction on HomeAdvisor). These accolades indicate the firm passed Angi’s background screening and maintained superior customer ratings over the year.
Summary: Sheiner Construction appears to meet all professional credentials expected of a reputable contractor. Homeowners should always verify a remodeler’s license and insurance before hiring; in this case Sheiner Construction’s credentials are confirmed to be in good standing.
Complaints or Legal Issues
Our research did not uncover any significant complaints, lawsuits, or legal problems involving Sheiner Construction. The BBB reports zero complaints on file (BBB Complaints), and we found no public records of disciplinary actions by the California Contractors State License Board (CSLB). The company has only been in business since late 2013 (Better Business Bureau), but in that time it has no known disputes with regulators or consumer agencies.
No negative reports surfaced in news articles or consumer forums specific to Sheiner Construction. In fact, the absence of complaints is reflected in their A+ BBB rating and the positive review landscape described above. Of course, as with any contractor, minor issues can occur during projects – but what stands out is Sheiner Construction’s proactive handling of problems (as noted in customer stories where any issues were resolved quickly and fairly) (Trustindex.io) (Sheiner Construction San Diego | Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io). There is no indication of red-flag behavior such as abandoned jobs, chronic over-budget projects, or legal disputes over liens.
One general caution: a few online commenters in local forums warn that some contractors may incentivize five-star reviews or that almost-perfect ratings should be viewed with healthy skepticism (Are there any general contractors in San Diego you would NOT recommend? : r/sandiego). Sheiner Construction is not mentioned there. Moreover – their clients’ praise appears genuine – but consumers should, as always, review contracts carefully and ensure clear communication to avoid misunderstandings. The bottom line is that we found no serious complaints or legal red flags tied to Sheiner Construction.
Industry Reputation and Awards
Within the San Diego remodeling industry, Sheiner Construction has built a strong reputation despite its relatively short history. It is frequently mentioned among the top remodeling contractors in the area. For example, a local real estate blog listed Sheiner Construction as a “trusted name in San Diego” known for stellar reviews and top-notch craftsmanship, calling it a “go-to choice” for homeowners seeking reliable and elegant remodels (Finding the Best Home Remodeling Companies in San Diego | Blog | The Comiskey Group). The company emphasizes a blend of modern design with functional, quality construction – an approach that resonates well in client testimonials and likely contributed to industry recognition.
Sheiner Construction has also earned accolades from home improvement networks. As noted, Angi (HomeAdvisor) honored the firm with its Super Service Award (Sheiner Construction | San Diego – HomeAdvisor), which is given to the top A-rated contractors in each market. Additionally, the company holds “Elite” status on these platforms, indicating high customer satisfaction and an excellent track record with homeowners. These awards and honors reflect both consistently high customer ratings and adherence to professional standards (e.g. background checks, licensing) required by the platforms.
It’s also worth noting that Sheiner’s BuildZoom score of 98 places it well above most peers in California (BuildZoom). BuildZoom’s score incorporates license status, project history, and client feedback, so such a high number reinforces that Sheiner Construction is regarded as a top performer among contractors. While they may not have decades of legacy awards (given its founding in 2013), its early achievements and reputation in the community suggest a company on par with longstanding, well-regarded remodelers in San Diego.
Comparison with Other San Diego Remodeling Companies
In the competitive San Diego home remodeling market, Sheiner Construction stands out for its near-perfect customer satisfaction record. Many established remodeling contractors in the area do have good reputations, but it’s relatively uncommon to see across-the-board 5-star ratings on every platform. For instance, other highly-rated firms like Cali Bath & Kitchen or Lusso Design-Build also maintain strong 5-star averages in reviews, but often with a smaller number of total reviews or a mix of some lower ratings. Sheiner Construction, by contrast, has accumulated dozens of reviews on Yelp and Angi/HomeAdvisor, all overwhelmingly positive (Trustindex.io) (HomeAdvisor). This suggests a level of consistency that rivals strive for – it’s currently ranked 5.0/5 on Yelp with no 4- or 3-star reviews in the main profile (sheiner-construction-san-diego- – Yahoo Local Search Results), which is exceptional.
In terms of quality and services, Sheiner Construction offers similar capabilities as its peers – full home remodels, kitchen and bath renovations, room additions, and even accessory dwelling unit (ADU) construction. Clients often choose a contractor based on trust and communication. Here, Sheiner Construction’s clients frequently emphasize how “honest, communicative and understanding” the team is (Sheiner Construction San Diego | Kitchen and Bathroom Remodeling Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io), which can give it an edge over larger companies that might feel less personal. While some bigger remodeling firms in San Diego have longer track records or larger portfolios, they may also have more mixed feedback in online reviews. Sheiner Construction’s family-run approach (it’s described as a family business on Houzz) seems to resonate well, translating into a friendly customer experience that competes strongly with other top contractors.
When comparing pricing and value, Sheiner Construction appears competitive. One Angi reviewer noted “they have some of the most cheapie quotes” (very budget-friendly) while still delivering 5-star quality and responsiveness (Sheiner Construction Reviews – San Diego, CA | Angi). This suggests Sheiner Construction often bids attractively against similar firms. Other top-rated remodelers in San Diego – for example, Marrokal Design, Kaminskiy Design & Remodeling, or Jackson Design & Remodeling – are well-known but typically command premium pricing. By comparison, Sheiner Construction’s clients feel they received excellent value for money, which is a key differentiator. Of course, exact costs depend on each project’s scope, but there’s no indication that Sheiner Construction’s pricing is out of line; in fact, several clients were pleased that the final cost “came in right on estimate” (Reviews | Trustindex.io).
Overall, relative to its peers, Sheiner Construction is viewed as one of the top remodeling companies in San Diego for customer satisfaction and quality. It competes effectively on communication and trustworthiness. Homeowners shopping around should still compare multiple bids (as a general best practice (BuildZoom) – however, Sheiner’s combination of glowing reviews, verified credentials, and project results put it in the same league as the best-known remodelers in the area, if not a step above many in terms of client happiness.
Conclusion
Is Sheiner Construction a reliable choice for a full house remodeling in San Diego? Based on the evidence, YES. This company has established a strong reputation for reliability, quality workmanship, and ethical business practices. Customers consistently report positive experiences – highlighting Sheiner’s on-time project completion, fair pricing, excellent communication, and willingness to go the extra mile to satisfy the client. The firm’s credentials (licensed, bonded, A+ BBB rating) and industry recognitions further bolster its trustworthiness. There is a notable track record of client trust – several reviews even come from repeat customers or referrals, indicating people come back to Sheiner Construction for additional projects and recommend it to friends (Sheiner Construction Reviews – San Diego on | Angi).
As for red flags, none stand out in public records or reviews. No patterns of complaints, legal troubles, or shoddy workmanship have surfaced. The only caution is the company’s relative newness – in operation just a few years (since 2013) – which means it doesn’t have decades of history to evaluate like the other companies. That said, in its few years of business it has performed impressively, and its team has over 15 years of experience according to their profile (the owners/operators were likely in the industry before launching the firm) (Profile for Sheiner Construction – Facebook). Customers should always ensure any contractor – even a well-reviewed one – provides a clear contract, proper permits, and open communication. In the case of Sheiner Construction, clients report the company excels in these areas (e.g. “we got to see the exact plans on paper first…they didn’t start demo until materials were ready” (Trustindex.io), and permits/inspections are handled professionally (Best 15 Home Remodelers in Carlsbad, CA | Houzz)).
In summary, Sheiner Construction appears to be a highly reliable choice for home remodeling in San Diego. Its nearly flawless customer feedback, verified quality of work, and clean record suggest you can expect professional, high-quality results. There are no significant red flags evident from our research. As with any project, it’s wise to maintain open communication about your expectations and budget – but homeowners can feel confident considering Sheiner Construction for their remodeling needs, given the company’s proven commitment to customer satisfaction and excellent workmanship (Finding the Best Home Remodeling Companies in San Diego | The Comiskey Group) (Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io).
